From our perspective, the single most important factor in pot selection is moisture management. Our roots require a careful balance of air and water. A pot that is excessively large relative to our root ball holds a significant volume of soil that our roots cannot access. This unused soil acts like a water reservoir, staying wet for prolonged periods after watering. This saturated environment suffocates our root systems, creating the perfect anaerobic conditions for the fungi that cause root rot to thrive. Therefore, the "best" size is one that allows for a small amount of growth without drowning us in soggy, unused soil.
The ideal pot size is one that is only 1 to 2 inches (2.5 to 5 cm) larger in diameter than the current root ball of your Fiddle Leaf Fig. When you slide us out of our nursery pot, the tight mass of roots and soil you see is our root ball. The new pot's interior diameter should be just slightly wider than this mass on all sides. This modest increase provides enough new territory for our roots to explore and expand into over the next 12-18 months, which encourages healthy growth. It also ensures that the volume of new soil is small enough that our roots can efficiently absorb the moisture within it, allowing the soil to dry out appropriately between waterings.
While width is the primary concern, depth is also crucial. A pot that is disproportionately deep creates a dangerous phenomenon we call a "perched water table." Water will always be pulled downward by gravity, but it is also held in the soil's tiny pores by capillary action. In a very deep pot, the weight of the water may not be sufficient to overcome this capillary hold in the lower soil layers, leaving a perpetually wet zone at the very bottom that our roots will avoid. This is why an excellent drainage hole is non-negotiable. It provides an essential escape route for excess water, preventing it from pooling at the base and significantly reducing the risk of rot. A pot must never let our root ball sit in standing water.
You will know it is time for a larger pot when you observe clear signs from us. The most definitive signal is when our roots begin to circle the inside of the pot or emerge from the drainage holes, indicating we have effectively filled the available space. Other signs include soil that dries out remarkably quickly (within just a few days) or a noticeable slowing of top growth despite adequate light and seasonal feeding. Repotting should ideally be done during our active growing season in spring or early summer, giving our roots the best chance to establish themselves in their new, slightly larger home without the stress of dormant periods.